[ mood |

geeky]
A reading update!
Lord of the Rings -
xThe Hobbit -
Jane Eyre -
xWuthering Heights -
xTess of the D'Urbervilles -
The Works of William Shakespeare (His comedies + tragedies [minus R&J, JC, Macbeth, Hamlet] + histories) -
UP NEXT!Rebecca -
Gone With the Wind -
Bleak House -
War & Peace -
Anna Karenina -
The Kite Runner -
Memoirs of a Geisha -
Love in the Time of Cholera -
Poisonwood Bible -
Doctor Zhivago -
As you may have observed, I have completed
Wuthering Heights.
I found it to be a vast deal darker than
Jane. While Charlotte Bronte in
Jane Eyre composes a slightly dark picture, I enjoyed how amidst that darkness she allowed light to escape through enough to keep my heart yearning for more. I attached myself more quickly to Jane - I felt pity & compassion for her oppressed state and kept hoping for better for her. And as I wished, Charlotte granted and better did arrive. To be honest, I've heard so many people describe Jane's experiences at her school in the book as afflicting, dark, and just as oppressive as they were at her previous home was. Not so, I'd say! Instead she found a wonderful friend and encouraging teachers (! : ) ) Though there is an antagonist in the mix (well, some may argue more than one), it still doesn't seem as depressing as everyone makes it out to be. This may be neither here nor there for some, but I enjoyed Charlotte's consistent references to God and having faith in the merits of persevering. Not only does Jane's friend describe her devotion, but Jane later makes comments & decisions that I couldn't help but smile with because she was sticking to her faith. I won't go too far into the detail for those who have not read it and do not wish for it to be spoiled. But oh the romance! Mr. Rochester isn't your run of the mill hero. If you were to try and compare him to an Austen-hero he'd draw closer to Darcy and Brandon more so than any of the others. He's rather broody and bit harsh at times, but when he softens..sweet and devoted he is! There's something that I did not find in many of the Austen novels which distinguishes this storyline: passion. Perhaps this is what drew me to Persuasion as being able to trump Pride & Prejudice on my favorites list, but there was constancy and passion with Anne & Wentworth, I felt. This is what sealed the deal with me and
Jane Eyre. There's struggle, happiness, love, separation, and delightful twists (& some unsettling ones, too). I love it! Jane is as wonderful a heroine - smart, decent, hopeful (& an educator!). I recommend it to anyone who delights in a bit more joy than gloom in their readings. Feel free to strike up a conversation if you'd like to hear more. But I shall desist on this subject for now and shift to Emily's work.
Oh Emily, Emily. What can I say about
Wuthering Heights? First off I felt as though it was a little slow to start (admittedly, so
was Jane Eyre). Granted, once Mrs. Dean started into her tails I was hooked, but prior to...I wondered where it was going. Well then, that being said, I don't think I have read a book with so much gloom in a long time. There are rays of hope and happy that peek through the clouds from time to time, but they seem to be squashed until the end. I liked the end, it felt like there was closure. For a while it seemed as though none would be reached and that the darkness would prevail. Don't get me wrong, I appreciate dark, I get it..and I understand why it was dark to begin with. Take Heathcliff for example - he was mistreated, looked down upon, and neglected. So yes, I see why he turned out as he did (though as manipulative and mean...eh, Emily at least wrote a good scoundrel there). Catherine too did not have a life of all sunshine and daisies. Still, I couldn't help feeling like they should, at any moment in time,
get over it. Perhaps I expected too much; perhaps I should have acknowledged that there are people/characters that will indeed live their lives all dark and twisty. I just don't know how much of that I like in my escapes from reality. I tried to attach myself to Cathy and Heathcliff, to root for them but where I thought I would find the passion that usually accompanies forbidden love, I found a lot of angst, arguing, and selfishness. I found myself wondering if it was really love or just obsession - bottled up desire was there, but it never seemed to be released to me (well, perhaps excepting one scene). I don't know if this is what was intended but I constantly felt sorry for Edgar Linton, hoping that he could be spared the hurt. I found some relief in the younger Catherine, she was less wild and seemingly less foolish. She struck me as stronger and, well, saner (this was probably written so because of her upbringing). I was annoyed with Linton Heathcliff and grew less, and less compassionate toward Heathcliff, Sr. Again, redemption lay in the ending - but even that was a little awkward. So in short, I liked it. I really did think it was well written and it had an intriguing storyline. I understand why it is a classic and why others like it. It just wasn't my cup of tea. I wanted to like it more, but I guess you can't force it. I guess I'm just too much of a Jane/
Jane girl at heart.
I think, for my next book, I'll have to choose that which may have a little bit more light. I won't sign off the rest of the books that are gloomy on the list just yet, I'll ponder them. But for now I think I'll reunite with my good friend Will Shakespeare. Even his tragedies tug at my heart, and I think that's what I need right now. I'm going to try to get through all the rest that I have not read, embarking on a bit of a Shakespeare extravaganza!